What’s the Best Fishing Subscription Box? – Reviews and Ratings

There are tons of fishing subscription boxes out there. They differ widely, however. Some are general fishing boxes with a little bit of everything, while others are centered around a particular type of fish. 

The best fishing subscription box depends largely on what fish you’re targeting. If you mostly fish a single species, you’ll benefit most from a box centered on that species.

For those that like catching a little bit of everything, a more multispecies box is the way to go. 

We’ve reviewed some of our favorite boxes below. On top of a general option, we’ve also reviewed one for bass, saltwater, and trout. 

Top 3 Fishing Subscription Boxes

Best for Bass	Best for Saltwater	Best for Trout
Monsterbass	Coastal Salt Box	Postfly

---

Best Overall Fishing Subscription Box

Mystery Tackle Box

Specs

• Cost: $9.99 – $39.99/month
• Value: $25 – $60 of gear
• What’s Included?: Lures, Tackle, and other “Fishing Stuff”

Pros:

• Wide-range of different products included
• Information on how to utilize all items in the box
• Several different tiers are available
• Great value

Cons:

• No refunds

The Mystery Tackle box allows you to choose from several fish species, including bass, walleye, and trout. You can also select generalized boxes, including some designed specifically for saltwater. 

Each monthly subscription box includes a range of lures, tackles, stickers, apparel, and other fishing-themed stuff. 

Several different tiers are available, depending on how much gear you want. Only certain species are available in the different tiers. For instance, the lower tiers have many different species, but the elite box has fewer to choose from. 

You can pause or cancel your subscription at any time. Shipping is free, and there is tons of information on the website about using all the different lures in the box. 

Best Bass Fishing Subscription Box

Monsterbass

Specs

• Cost: $20 – $38/month
• Value: Around $50
• What’s Included?: Bass lures specific to your region

Pros:

• Custom box based on your location
• Curated range of lures
• Several bass species provided
• Excellent customer service

Cons:

• No refunds

When signing up for the Monsterbass box, you’ll fill out several questions, such as your location, skill level, and fishing style.

Then, each monthly box is curated based on your answer to each question. Therefore, you’ll receive exactly what you need to fish bass in your area. 

You’ll find many guides and tutorials on their website, as well. If you get a bass lure you don’t know how to use, you can often find directions online. 

The company offers several tiers. The most basic tier offers 5+ lures and baits for bass. The higher the tier goes, the more lures you’ll receive. Higher tiers also get other benefits, like free bait and gift cards. 

Best Saltwater Fishing Subscription Box

Coastal Salt Box

Specs

• Cost: $30 – $70/month
• Value: $50 – $150
• What’s Included?: Premium gear for saltwater anglers

Pros:

• Personalized to your region and season
• Several different tiers available
• Skip a month at any time (or even double up)
• Products from top brands

Cons:

• Customer service issues

The Coastal Salt Box provides gear specifically for saltwater anglers. Depending on your budget, the company offers three boxes for you to choose from. 

While all the boxes have the same gear, higher tiers provide more of everything and offshore gear. According to the company, the box value is about double what you pay. 

In my experience, the box includes mostly lures, hooks, rigged lines, and similar items. Each box is personalized to your region and the current season.

You can also choose back bay or inshore fishing. Higher box tiers offer offshore saltwater fishing, too. Therefore, not everyone will receive the same thing. 

You can cancel, skip, or pause your order at any time. You can double up one month (perfect for gifting to your fishing friends).

The box is always delivered at the end of the month, and shipping is always free within the United States. 

Best Trout Fishing Subscription Box

Postfly

Specs

• Cost: $28 – $50/month
• Value: $50+
• What’s Included?: “Everything you need,” including flies and gear

Pros:

• Several species are available, including trout
• Three tiers
• Several stand-alone boxes are available
• Exclusive gear in the top-tier box

Cons:

• Expensive

For trout anglers, the Postfly box includes everything you need to get fishing right away. The company claims that its boxes include “everything you need.”

You can choose from several different tiers. Two tiers cost the same, but one is based on fly tying. You can learn a new recipe monthly with this box or select their “regular” fly fishing box. 

Their top-tier box includes more of everything in the regular box and some premium flies. It’s nearly twice as expensive as the other options, though.

You can select from several different species, including a more general “warm water” box. Each box includes flies and information on how to use them.

If you choose the fly-tying box, you’ll get pre-portioned materials, one complete set, and everything you need to make several flies yourself. In the end, Postfly is easily the best fly fishing subscription box.

Factors to Consider Before Buying a Fishing Subscription Box

When you subscribe to a fishing box, you rely on the company to curate fishing gear. Luckily, these boxes often save you money, assuming you use everything in them.

Therefore, the key to choosing a quality box is to find one with items you’ll use. 

Of course, you also want a top-quality box with premium items for an affordable price. Let’s look at each of these factors, in turn, to help you choose the perfect box. 

Species

The first factor to consider when looking at a monthly fishing box is the species it is made for.

The Mystery Tackle box provides the choice of bass, inshore saltwater, panfish & trout, or walleye. Often, you can change the species at any time, allowing you to dabble in several different species if you choose. 

Even the best tackle box subscription won’t be helpful if you don’t target the species it centers around. 

Contents

Next, take a look at what the box includes. The best monthly fishing box will include tons of fishing gear, including lures, tackle, premium products, and fishing-themed items.

Preferably, the monthly fishing box contains a large enough range of items to ensure that there is something you’ll use. 

Avoid boxes that seem to contain more fish-themed items than fighting gear. Sure, a sticker or two can be fun. However, you don’t want four out of the eight items in your box to be stickers.

Preferably, you want as many lures and tackle as possible.

Watch unboxing videos or look at reviews like ours for examples of what each box includes. Of course, fishing subscription boxes change monthly and depend on how you personalize them. 

Therefore, you won’t get exactly what is listed in the examples, but they will give you a good idea of what to expect. 

Value

Most subscription boxes have a higher value than what you pay. Often, the company purchases lots of gear in bulk, allowing them to put it in boxes for less than the retail price.

Using a subscription box, you can save a lot on gear. 

With that said, different boxes do have different values. Some may be about the same as what you paid, while others will be much more. 

Of course, more value is always better. Just be sure that you will use whatever gear comes in the bag. Even if the value is great on paper, it largely depends on if you use all the gear in the subscription box. 

Cost

You’re the only one who knows your budget. Therefore, you should ensure you choose a box well within your budget. 

Luckily, most subscription boxes have several tiers for you to choose from. Many boxes are around $20 for the lowest tier, while the more expensive boxes may be closer to $70. 

You should choose the best box for your budget while considering the factors above. 

Many boxes may provide discounts if you commit to several months or even a year. However, you cannot cancel these longer subscriptions, so you may lose money in the long run if your first box is lower quality. 

Be sure to count for shipping, too. Many boxes provide free shipping, but others may charge you $8+ to get the box shipped. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

There are many different monthly bait clubs out there. 

Most boxes cater to a specific species or type of fishing, though, so it’s important to look carefully at what each box does. The best box for you is one that caters to your specific fishing style and favorite species. 

For many, we recommend the Mystery Tacklebox. It includes many different species to choose from and high-quality items.

You can switch species at any time or stick to your favorite. For many, this is the best fishing subscription box.

We also included several options targeting the specific species above. If you’re a bass angler or saltwater fisherman, we’ve included boxes above that may suit you.